All Engines
Financial & Trend

Geographic Normalization Engine

Adjust Healthcare Costs for Regional Price Differences—Compare New York to Alabama Apples-to-Apples

The Geographic Cost Distortion

Raw Cost Comparisons

  • NYC office spends $15K PMPY, Alabama office $8K PMPY — which is efficient?
  • Cannot compare multi-state employers without geographic adjustment
  • Trend analysis contaminated by office relocations or workforce shifts
  • National benchmarks meaningless without regional cost indexing

Geographic Normalization

  • CBSA-level cost indexing: Manhattan 1.32x, Birmingham 0.78x national avg
  • Apples-to-apples comparisons: NYC $11.4K normalized, Alabama $10.3K normalized
  • Clean trend analysis: workforce migration doesn't distort performance
  • Fair benchmarking: compare to regional peers, not national averages

CBSA Geographic Indexing

python
# Geographic Cost Adjustment Framework geographic_indices = { 'NY-Newark-Jersey City': { 'cbsa_code': '35620', 'medical_index': 1.32, 'pharmacy_index': 1.08, 'mental_health_index': 1.18 }, 'Birmingham-Hoover, AL': { 'cbsa_code': '13820', 'medical_index': 0.78, 'pharmacy_index': 0.92, 'mental_health_index': 0.85 }, 'San Francisco-Oakland-Berkeley': { 'cbsa_code': '41860', 'medical_index': 1.45, 'pharmacy_index': 1.12, 'mental_health_index': 1.28 }, 'National Average': { 'medical_index': 1.00, 'pharmacy_index': 1.00, 'mental_health_index': 1.00 } } def normalize_costs_by_geography(member_costs, member_locations): normalized_costs = [] for member in member_costs: cbsa = member_locations[member.id].cbsa_code region_index = geographic_indices[cbsa] # Normalize Each Cost Component normalized_medical = member.medical_costs / region_index['medical_index'] normalized_rx = member.rx_costs / region_index['pharmacy_index'] normalized_mh = member.mental_health_costs / region_index['mental_health_index'] normalized_total = normalized_medical + normalized_rx + normalized_mh normalized_costs.append({ 'member_id': member.id, 'actual_costs': member.total_costs, 'normalized_costs': normalized_total, 'cbsa': cbsa, 'adjustment_factor': member.total_costs / normalized_total }) return normalized_costs # Example: Multi-State Employer Comparison # Location 1: New York (1.32x index) # - Actual PMPY: $15,000 # - Normalized PMPY: $11,364 ($15K / 1.32) # # Location 2: Birmingham (0.78x index) # - Actual PMPY: $8,000 # - Normalized PMPY: $10,256 ($8K / 0.78) # # Conclusion: Birmingham is actually LESS efficient than NYC # when adjusted for regional cost differences.

Regional Intelligence

Geographic Coverage
929 CBSAs
Core-Based Statistical Areas covering entire US
Cost Variance Range
0.65x to 1.55x
Lowest (rural Montana) to highest (Manhattan)
Adjustment Precision
Service-Level
Separate indices for medical, Rx, mental health

Fair Comparisons

Multi-State Cost Analysis

  • 5 offices: NYC, SF, Chicago, Dallas, Birmingham
  • Raw PMPY: NYC $16K, SF $18K, Birmingham $8.5K
  • After normalization: NYC $12.1K, SF $12.4K, Birmingham $10.9K
  • Birmingham appears cheapest raw, but least efficient normalized
  • Focus improvement efforts on Birmingham operations

Workforce Migration Impact

  • 2024: 60% NYC, 40% remote to lower-cost states
  • 2025: 40% NYC, 60% remote
  • Raw trend: -8.5% PMPY (looks like huge win)
  • Normalized trend: -2.1% PMPY (actual performance)
  • Prevented false sense of improvement from geography shift

Regional Benchmarking

  • Boston office: $14.2K PMPY actual, $11.8K normalized
  • Regional benchmark (Boston CBSA): $12.5K normalized
  • 6% below regional average (efficient)
  • Would appear 23% above national $11.5K without normalization
  • Fair performance assessment drives correct strategy

Compare Costs Fairly Across Geographies

Adjust for regional cost differences across 929 CBSAs. Make apples-to-apples comparisons. Identify true performance vs. geographic artifacts.

Normalize Costs