PBM Contract Clarity 360° Full Report

Hamilton County × Anthem 2025

Forensic analysis of 2025 Anthem administrative services agreement with Pharmacy Services Schedule (CarelonRx) — 13 provisions, 60 checks

Hamilton County, Indiana
Anthem/CarelonRx
Score 18/100 - RED FLAG
November 13, 2026

Composite Score

0/100

RED FLAG band (below 40)

Medical Rebates

0%

Retained by Anthem

Savings Fee

0%

Paid back to Anthem

Score Path

+0

Points to aligned (75)

Report Sections
Navigate analysis
The One-Page Verdict
Eight clauses. Twenty-two findings. One score: 18.

Sixty checks across thirteen provisions were run against the 2025 Anthem agreement. Twenty-two land on contract language that works against the county, and all twenty-two rest on just eight clauses. The other thirty-eight are silences: questions the county is entitled to ask and Anthem should answer in writing.

Key Findings:

100% Medical Drug Rebates Retained by Anthem

Complete Pass-Through Gap

Manufacturer payments on drugs billed through medical plan stay with Anthem. County funds claims, keeps none of rebate money. 43% of employers receive at least some medical rebates.

50% Savings Fee Structure

Half of Reported Savings

On network and non-network claims, Anthem earns half the gap between billed charges and plan payment. Rewards high starting price as much as low final one.

Pharmacy Carve-Out Exit Toll

Uncapped Fee Reopener

If county terminates Pharmacy Services Schedule, Anthem may amend administrative fees with no cap. Reopener prices every competing PBM bid before requested.

Provider Contracts Govern Pricing

Unknown Reimbursement Terms

Provider contracts county cannot read govern rates, adjustment windows, and high-dollar review. Agreement can be overridden by documents outside it.

Zero-Day Policy Change Notice

Unilateral Contract Modification

Anthem's policies apply 'as amended from time to time' with 0 days required notice. Contract can be rewritten by policy memo.

What the County Should Do First

"Send us Schedule A, a 2025 report of Medical Drug Rebates collected on county claims, and a written cap on any fee change tied to a pharmacy carve-out."

Get Your PBM Contract Clarity 360° Analysis

Flat $500 fee • 24-hour delivery • Forensic-grade analysis revealing hidden costs, contract vulnerabilities, and fiduciary exposure