Forensic analysis of Zywave, Inc. revealing 65.4% voluntary commission rate at 98th percentile nationally
This broker compensation study reveals a 65.4% commission rate on voluntary benefits, placing Zywave at the 98th percentile nationally. While core medical, dental, and vision lines are competitively priced (12-16th percentile), the voluntary commission rate is nearly double the typical 30-40% market range.
Total broker compensation increased 54% year-over-year, from $35,743 in 2024 to $55,111 in 2025. On a per-participant basis, this represents a cost increase from $69 to $109 per covered life (+57.5%), despite enrollment growing only modestly from 518 to 506 participants.
The addition of Brown & Brown as a second broker in 2025 (alongside incumbent Willis Towers Watson Midwest) introduces complexity without disclosed coordination benefits. The dual-broker structure warrants scrutiny to ensure no redundant fees or service overlap.
Recommended action: Request voluntary commission rate reduction to align with 30-40% market standard, saving approximately $15,000-$20,000 annually. Clarify the roles and fee allocation between the two brokers.
Get forensic-grade analysis of your broker's compensation structure with complete evidence documentation. $500 flat fee, 24-hour delivery.